New Wave Battle Type Concept: Judging

In many competitions judges are selected and there is a rubric to go by for judging.  In the past judging of wave battles has been biased I think on varying circomestances.

I think waves should be judged Boxing Round style, each category being a round. 
You could do public scoring, or do a private battle where 3 360 vets are chosen as the designated judges.  After viewing all photos, they would release the scores judges as such. 

For example
 
Waver 1 vs. 2

Connection:Waver 1 wins 10-8
Overall Visibility:Waver 1 wins 10-9
Top: Tie 10-10
Left: Waver 2 wins 10-8
Right Waver 2 wins 10-9
Back: Waver 1 wins 10-8
Crown: Waver 2 wins 10-9

10-9 is they won but it was close, 10-8 is they pretty much obviously won, and 10-7 would just be like wow one guy has a crazy spinnin side and the other guy got no waves there.
lol if we know they kitted dq... jp but

I think this could make things more interesting, and even more fair.  Its just an idea tho guys, so dont juz hate n diss the idea

great idea i wonder what the others think of this??? i Like it  and it haz my votes and i say only votes that should be calculated (counted iz those who are in the 360 vet club... or can get in dat room cause we ware fair,,,

Sounds interest but that would cut back on taking pics on angles lol it could be good but we should have a vote a couple days before a battle so we can pic 3 judges to judge this battle

ChristianTN8IS wrote: In many competitions judges are selected and there is a rubric to go by for judging.  In the past judging of wave battles has been biased I think on varying circomestances.

Sounds like a good idea , Sleepy if you set up the pols make sure that the people nominated to judge a battle are impartial and shows no favoritism towards anybody, it has to be straight down the middle if I feel like a battle isn't getting called down the middle like if I see a call blatantly go against the opponent then the judge will be replaced with someone who stands to gain nothing from the victor of the battle.  I like the idea though it would definitely set us apart from the other sites.

Edited by jamaicakid85 - October 23 2007 at 5:44am

he well put up all the 360 vets in the poll that are ACTIVE!!!! i wanna use this system un my battle on monday....

Just randomly nominate people not every Vet can be in it we can switch judging duties monthly.

^... uh, dub c is the most biased vet here

Gristyle wrote: Sounds interest but that would cut back on taking pics on angles lol it could be good but we should have a vote a couple days before a battle so we can pic 3 judges to judge this battle

The angle pics should be included to help your connection score. 
Also, I just picked what I thought would be the best round scores, if you guys have any other ideas for ways to rate, feel free to share because they aren't set in stone yet.

Maybe we can add cleanness as a category?  Like quality of the edgeups?  Hmm

I would have said depth, but its kind of unfair as depth is undeniably hugely factored by texture.  and + somebody wolfin week 10 is gonna beat somebody with a 1.5WTG for depth too.

stormy_seas wrote: ^... uh, dub c is the most biased vet here he said my waves were crap because of my 1 criss cross you know if he ever disputed w/ someone he would vote against them and overly criticize   not hatin, but i hope you can see that