QuoteReplyTopic: Vitamin E -- found something interesting....... Posted: January 12 2000 at 7:01am
http://hometown.aol.com/hairbook/secret.htmTowards the bottom of the page, under "Diet and your Hair,"I quote:"Consuming extra protein or amino acid preparations will not promote hair growth. In fact, there is evidence that megadoses of some vitamins-particularly A and E may contribute to hair loss."I'm just doing more searching around for hair care advice and thought this was interesting, since I've heard others tout quite the opposite.The more I read the more I'm convinced that having a great-looking head of hair is like having a perfectly sculpted body. Sure, supplements will help a little bit, but genetics plays a MUCH larger role. The sad part is that often guys with great-looking bodies sometimes got that way largely through genetics and really aren't the ones who are the experts to give advice. The same with hair -- some women with gorgeous, healthy hair aren't necessarily the experts when it comes to knowing what is truly good for the hair. That's absolutely directed towards no one in particular, but I've heard some very long-haired ladies say that they rarely trim their hair and take little or no particular care in their choice of hair care or products. Although it's tempting to take their advice because of their great-looking hair, others who try the same approach may end up with drastically different results!FWIW,Jena
Hi Jena,You bring up a very interesting subject. There has been lots of controversy on the topic of hair health, genetics, and supplements. Some people say that supplements play no role, only genetics do. Others think that no matter what your genetical background, your intake of supplements will affect the way your body looks. My personal belief is that hair health depends on a combination of both genetics and food.>Sure, supplements will help a little bit, but genetics >plays a MUCH larger role.You are absolutely right. But a person who is not getting the proper nutrition will not have healthy hair no matter how "good" their genes are. However, a person with "good" genes will require less supplements than a person with "bad" genes in order to have nice hair. In a similar way, a person who does not have the genetics for perfect hair will benefit from supplements because their hair will reach its potential. This does not mean that vitamins and minerals will make grow 4 inches a month, thick, and with no split ends. All it meant is that it will be slightly (or for some people, a lot) healtier than it would have been otherwise.> "Consuming extra protein or amino acid preparations will >not promote hair growth.Consuming "extra" protein/amino acids won't do the body any good, asuming that the body already has as much as it needs. But most of us don't eat quite that healthy.Think about it. The body uses an X ampount of vitamins, minerals, and other goodies for various cellular functions. If a person is not getting enough of a certain vitamin/mineral, for example, protein, then the body has to decide where to send the little amouts of protein that it's getting. Hair is not as important as, let's say, muscle development, so the protein gets set to the muscle cells insted of the hair. But if the person begins to eat more protein, and the muscle cells are now getting enough of it, then the body can aford to send protein to other, less important areas, such as hair. The hair, which previously was not getting proper nourishment (protein IS important in hair growth), now gets to enjoy a good supply of protein. It makes sense that the hair begins to grow healthier than before. This is true of other supplements as well. So I don't understand how a "scientific" article can say that supplements will not affect the hair's health. Common sense along with the experiences of many people dictate otherwise. But like you said, genetics help even more than supplements!It is true what the article said about megadoses of Vitamin A being toxic, although I have never heard of anyone getting sick over Vitamin E. However, too much of anything is bad, not just Vitamins A and E. Doesn't mean that they are not healthy. Just means that you have to know the amount your body needs. Notice that the article was talking about "MEGAdoses." Amounts of 400-800IU of vitamin E daily are quite healthy; in fact, you probably don't need any more than that. But the way that the article said it, it sound almost as if vitamin E is dangerous and sould be avoided, where as your body does need it a lot. Just don't drink it by the glass, and you'll be fine:)Thanks for bringing this up. I find this subject fascinating, and I am always interested in people's opinions.Happy holidays,PD> http://hometown.aol.com/hairbook/secret.htm> Towards the bottom of the page, under "Diet and> your Hair,"> I quote:> "Consuming extra protein or amino acid> preparations will not promote hair growth. In fact,> there is evidence that megadoses of some> vitamins-particularly A and E may contribute to hair> loss."> I'm just doing more searching around for hair care> advice and thought this was interesting, since I've> heard others tout quite the opposite.> The more I read the more I'm convinced that having a> great-looking head of hair is like having a perfectly> sculpted body. Sure, supplements will help a little> bit, but genetics plays a MUCH larger role. The sad> part is that often guys with great-looking bodies> sometimes got that way largely through genetics and> really aren't the ones who are the experts to give> advice. The same with hair -- some women with> gorgeous, healthy hair aren't necessarily the experts> when it comes to knowing what is truly good for the> hair. That's absolutely directed towards no one in> particular, but I've heard some very long-haired> ladies say that they rarely trim their hair and take> little or no particular care in their choice of hair> care or products. Although it's tempting to take their> advice because of their great-looking hair, others who> try the same approach may end up with drastically> different results!> FWIW,> Jena
Hi PD,>This does not> mean that vitamins and minerals will make grow 4> inches a month, thick, and with no split ends.Can you imagine owning stock in the company that might actually produce a hair remedy like this!?!I agree totally with your assessment of vitamins. If we ate foods that gave us the perfect proportion of all the vitamins and minerals we need, then supplements wouldn't increase our potential for perfect hair any more. The vitamins and minerals are only to be used as filling in the pieces of the nutritional jigsaw puzzle. What is amazing, though, is that a 100% breastfed baby *does* receive every single vitamin and mineral his body needs in the exact perfect proportion! Now, if we could only continue with that perfect diet!> So I don't understand how a> "scientific" article can say that> supplements will not affect the hair's health.I think what they mean to say is that extra supplementation over and above what the body normally needs will not affect hair's health.>But like you said, genetics help> even more than supplements!I wish it weren't so! But it simply is. Back to the bodybuilding example, I've seen guys really bulk out but who used terrible form (and not surprisingly found themselves with torn muscles and injuries later on....) and I've seen guys who could lift tremendous weights yet whose bodies barely looked thick at all. Same with hair. Hair that is not abused but also has not been particularly taken special care of can still be quite thick and beautiful yet hair that has been treated with kid gloves may not resemble a healthy-looking head of hair at all. But since most of us here actually bothered to spend time on a website devoted to hair care, hopefully we're all doing the best that we can!> It is true what the article said about megadoses of> Vitamin A being toxic, although I have never heard of> anyone getting sick over Vitamin E.Since vitamin E is not water soluable, it can build up in the body. A few years back, several babies became ill because of vitamin E overdose -- their breastfeeding moms used vitamin E oil on the nipples to prevent soreness and the vitamin E in the oil was absorbed by the baby. Any non-water soluable vitamins have the potential of building up dangerously in the body. I think niacin is non-water soluable (but I'm not exactly certain), but I do know that it can cause problems if too much is consumed.>But the way that the article said it, it> sound almost as if vitamin E is dangerous and sould be> avoided, where as your body does need it a lot. Just> don't drink it by the glass, and you'll be fine:)Oh, and I so enjoyed that vitamin E cocktail in the evening. {grin}> Thanks for bringing this up. I find this subject> fascinating, and I am always interested in people's> opinions.Me, too! And the more I read, the more I find out I *don't* know!Happy New Year!Jena
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot create polls in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum